Home/Peer Review and Editorial Assessment

Journal of Pediatric Dental Health (JPDH)

Peer Review and Editorial Assessment

Peer Review Policy

The Journal of Pediatric Dental Health (JPDH) is an independent, double-blind, anonymous, peer-reviewed journal that follows a double-anonymised peer-review process. The identities of authors and reviewers are kept confidential and are not disclosed to each other during the review process. All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial editorial screening within seven days to assess their relevance to the journal, originality, scientific quality, completeness, and compliance with submission guidelines and ethical requirements. Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements may be returned for correction or rejected without external peer review.

Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are assigned to a handling editor and normally sent to two independent reviewers with expertise in the relevant subject area. Reviewers are selected based on their academic qualifications, research experience, and ability to provide an impartial assessment. They examine the study design, methodology, statistical analysis, ethical considerations, results, discussion, and conclusions. Supplementary materials submitted with the manuscript are also reviewed. Reviewers must declare any competing interests before accepting an invitation.

Reviewers are given 21 days to submit their reports, and the journal aims to communicate the first editorial decision within 40 days of submission. Based on the reviewers' recommendations and the editor's assessment, a manuscript may be accepted, returned for minor or major revision, or rejected. When reviewers provide conflicting recommendations, an additional independent review may be requested. The review period may be extended when specialist assessment is required or unexpected delays occur, and authors will be informed of significant delays.

Authors are allowed 14 days for minor revisions and 30 days for major revisions. Revised manuscripts must be accompanied by a point-by-point response to the reviewers' comments, explaining the changes made. Authors who disagree with a recommendation may provide a scientific explanation supported by relevant evidence. Extensions may be granted upon request. Revised manuscripts may be assessed by the handling editor or returned to the reviewers for further evaluation.

All manuscripts, reviewer reports, supplementary materials, and editorial correspondence are treated as confidential. Reviewers must not share unpublished material, discuss manuscripts with unauthorised individuals, or use information obtained during peer review for personal benefit. Reviewer identities and reports remain confidential and are not published alongside accepted articles. Editors and reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts or related materials to external artificial intelligence platforms without the journal's permission and appropriate safeguards. Artificial intelligence must not replace independent scientific assessment, and any permitted AI assistance in preparing a review must be disclosed to the handling editor.

The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision on manuscript acceptance or rejection after considering the reviewers' reports and the handling editor's recommendations. Editorial decisions are based on scientific merit, originality, ethical standards, and relevance to pediatric dentistry. The publisher, advertisers, sponsors, and article processing charges have no influence over manuscript evaluation or acceptance. Manuscripts submitted by editors, editorial board members, or individuals associated with the publisher are handled by an independent editor without competing interests and undergo the same peer-review process as other submissions.

Original research articles, review articles, systematic reviews, meta-analyses, case reports, and other scholarly manuscripts undergo external peer review. Editorials, announcements, and other non-research content may be assessed by the editorial team without external review, and their review status will be clearly stated in the published article. Following acceptance, the journal aims to complete copyediting, typesetting, author proofreading, and online publication within 21 days, subject to completion of the necessary publication formalities. Authors may submit complaints or appeal editorial decisions through the journal's established complaints and appeals procedure.

Reviewer Selection and Confidentiality

The Journal of Pediatric Dental Health (JPDH) follows an independent, double-blind, anonymous peer-review process. The handling editor appoints two independent reviewers based on their expertise and research experience. Authors may suggest reviewers, but the final selection rests with the editor. Reviewers must declare any conflicts of interest and maintain strict confidentiality throughout the review process. Manuscripts and related materials must not be shared with others or uploaded to external artificial intelligence platforms without the editor's permission and appropriate safeguards. Reviewers must provide an impartial scientific assessment, submit their comments within 21 days, and inform the editor if additional time is required. Reviewer identities and reports remain confidential and are not published.

Editorial Decision-Making and Independence

Editorial Decision-Making and Independence Policy

Editorial decisions at the Journal of Pediatric Dental Health (JPDH) are made independently of the publisher, advertisers, sponsors, and publication charges. Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening are sent to two independent reviewers for scientific assessment. The handling editor examines both reviewers' reports and communicates the decision to the authors. If both reviewers recommend acceptance, the manuscript is considered for final approval after the editor confirms that all scientific and ethical requirements have been met. If revisions are recommended, the authors must address the reviewers' comments before a further decision is made. Where reviewers disagree, the editor may seek a third independent opinion. The Editor-in-Chief has final responsibility for accepting or rejecting manuscripts. Editors with competing interests must withdraw from the assessment, and submissions from editorial board members or individuals associated with the publisher are handled by an independent editor. Editors involved in manuscript decisions do not participate in decisions concerning publication fees or waivers. All decisions are based on scientific merit, originality, ethical standards, and relevance to the journal.